EW Computation (further discussion opened by Marco)

Show your spectra, your results ...

EW Computation (further discussion opened by Marco)

Postby Francois Teyssier » Sat Nov 05, 2011 6:31 pm

Further discussion opened by Marco on spectro-l list.

I used the spectrum sent by Marco in my excel spreadsheet.

The results are :

Direct computation ( simple integration) EW = 16.03
Image


Gaussian fit : EW = 15.93 and center = 6562.81 (excellent wavelenght calibration, Marco !)
(The Gaussian fit is a simple gaussian curve, with one compound).
Image

Less than 1% diffrence between the two measurements.

Determining the edges of the line does not pose problems
Here's the integration range is [6553,6573]
If I adopt the range used by Marco [6548,6578], the EW becomes 15.96 : only 0.7% difference.


The real difficulty is : where is the continuum ?

François Teyssier
Attachments
kapdra_ew_gauss.PNG
kapdra_ew_gauss.PNG (15.08 KiB) Viewed 2197 times
kapdra_ew.PNG
kapdra_ew.PNG (17.12 KiB) Viewed 2197 times
Francois Teyssier
 
Posts: 1345
Joined: Fri Sep 23, 2011 1:01 pm
Location: Rouen

Re: EW Computation (further discussion opened by Marco)

Postby Marco Leonardi » Sat Nov 05, 2011 7:24 pm

François,

I agree that this forum should be the first point of reference for discussion like this. Thanks to open this topic in ARAS and to spend some of your time on my kap Dra spectra.

I take the opportunity to correct the software table comparison I posted yesterday, and after Benjamin MAUCLAIRE today post in spectro-l the new table is the following:

1. SpcAud’ACE (V2.10) command spc_ew kapdra 6548 6578 6 n 0 = -16.28
2. VSpec (V4.0.0) console command: Comp l 6548 6578 gives EW = -15.9
3. VSpec (V4.0.0) option EW lin fit = -15.905
4. VSpec (V4.0.0) option EW cst fit = -15.908
5. VSpec (V4.0.0) option EW cst 1 = -16.285
6. ISIS (V3.3.1) EW = -16.28
7. SPLAT (V3.9-6) Quick fit EW = -16.3

So all softwares seems to be in-line and your further confirmation is another important cross-check.

Another point is a link just posted in spectro-l by Stan Gorodensky related with EW computation. I did not read the pdf but I think it should be very interesting and probably can help to understand more about the question: where is the continuum ?

http://www.socastrosci.org/images/SAS_Vol_9_2.pdf

Regards,

Marco Leonardi
Marco Leonardi
 
Posts: 30
Joined: Thu Sep 29, 2011 6:48 am
Location: Milan - Italy

Re: EW Computation (further discussion opened by Marco)

Postby Benjamin Mauclaire » Thu Nov 10, 2011 3:25 pm

Hi,

I've made a tutorial about how to compute EW with SpcAudace in few different situation depending on the continuum:

http://bmauclaire.free.fr/spcaudace/docs/ew

Assumed that main factor that impact on EW has been set to continuum moldelisation as describe in OHP2010 workshop:

http://bmauclaire.free.fr/astronomie/sp ... iences/ew/

Benji
Spcaudace spectroscopy software: saving you hundred hours of frustration.
Benjamin Mauclaire
 
Posts: 234
Joined: Thu Sep 29, 2011 10:14 am


Return to Spectra, results, information on activity ...

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest

x