Page 11 of 13

Re: Alert! Nova Cas 2021 mag 9

Posted: Mon Oct 18, 2021 10:56 am
by Joan Guarro Flo
Hello,

The little changes continuing in NOVA Cas 2021, you can see details of that in this graphics and the test improvement on the NOU_T results
from SMM Remote Observatory.

Cheers, J.Guarro.

Re: Alert! Nova Cas 2021 mag 9

Posted: Wed Oct 27, 2021 9:09 am
by Joan Guarro Flo
Hello,

Nova Cas 2021 is follow showing variations in its blue region.


Cheers, J.Guarro.

Re: Alert! Nova Cas 2021 mag 9

Posted: Sun Oct 31, 2021 9:29 am
by Christophe Boussin
Hello all,

It's with great pleasure that I resume my "storytelling" of the Halpha line of Nova Cas 2021...which continues to make the show ;) !

I obtained eight new high resolution spectra of the Halpha line on September 16 at 21 h 35 TU (resolution of 18183, JJ = 2459474.3993, 9 x 600s), on September 23 at 20 h 42 TU (resolution of 18118, JJ = 2459481.3622, 9 x 600s), on September 24 at 21 h 33 TU (resolution of 17108, JJ = 2459482.3982, 9 x 600s), on September 30 at 22 h 22 TU (resolution of 16869, JJ = 2459488.4322, 8 x 600s), on October 4 at 19 h 43 TU (resolution of 18860, JJ = 2459492.3213, 5 x 600s), on October 19 at 18 h 35 TU (resolution of 19383, JJ = 2459507.2741, 8 x 600s), on October 23 at 18 h 20 TU (resolution of 12885, JJ = 2459511.2641, 7 x 600s) and on October 27 at 20 h 34 TU (resolution of 19457, JJ = 2459515.3567, 9 x 600s) with my LHIRES III (grating of 2400 lines / mm).

Here are all the spectra I got between September 16th and October 27th :
Halpha line profile of the Nova CAS 2021 on September 16th, 23th, 24th, 30th and on October 4th, 19th, 23th and 27th 2021
Halpha line profile of the Nova CAS 2021 on September 16th, 23th, 24th, 30th and on October 4th, 19th, 23th and 27th 2021
novacas2021_20210916_20211027_Christophe Boussin.png (52.91 KiB) Viewed 7037 times
On the following graph, we can note that the shape of the Halpha line profile in the "blue" part has evolved very clearly during the last few days between October 23 and 27 !!
Halpha line profile of the Nova CAS 2021 on September 16th, 23th, 24th, 30th and on October 4th, 19th, 23th and 27th 2021 (zoom)
Halpha line profile of the Nova CAS 2021 on September 16th, 23th, 24th, 30th and on October 4th, 19th, 23th and 27th 2021 (zoom)
novacas2021_20210916_20211027_Christophe Boussin_zoom.png (48.22 KiB) Viewed 7037 times
According to the AAVSO website, the magnitude of the Nova Cas 2021 has continued to oscillate in recent weeks.

(Johnson V : green squares)
Light curve of the Nova CAS 2021 (AAVSO)
Light curve of the Nova CAS 2021 (AAVSO)
I wish you all very clear skies !!

Christophe BOUSSIN

Re: Alert! Nova Cas 2021 mag 9

Posted: Mon Nov 22, 2021 1:13 pm
by Joan Guarro Flo
Hello,

It seems that Nitrogen bands have appareaded these last few days.

J.Guarro.

Re: Alert! Nova Cas 2021 mag 9

Posted: Mon Nov 22, 2021 10:51 pm
by Francois Teyssier
Yes, Joan,
Just add [ ] as they are "forbidden" (more correctly: collisionally excited) lines.
It began to appear at the begining of the month.
RSOph_2021-11-19_[NII]5755.png
RSOph_2021-11-19_[NII]5755.png (34.99 KiB) Viewed 6375 times
It means that some parts of the nebula form by the outburst have now a low electronic density, 8 months after the outburst!

What is strange:
- The first forbidden lines to appear in the classical development of a nova are [OI], still absent.
- We have a. [NII] : low density and b. P cygni profile for He I 5876 (i.e.: opacity, high density).
Very unusual.
novacas2021_NII.png
novacas2021_NII.png (41.31 KiB) Viewed 6406 times
Correction to line identification of [NII] 6548, 6583:
A clue: Compare H alpha, H beta, He I profiles using PlotSpectra



Of course, more data are needed.
Nova Cas 2021 is very well placed in the evening night..
I got a spectrum this evening. To be process.

All the best,
François

Re: Alert! Nova Cas 2021 mag 9

Posted: Fri Nov 26, 2021 2:54 am
by James Ley
Thanks for your explanations François.
Are those not emissions for NIII at 4638 and HeII at 4686? Since the ionization potentials for N, N+ and He are all greater than for O, does one expect to see [OI]?

Re: Alert! Nova Cas 2021 mag 9

Posted: Fri Nov 26, 2021 4:46 pm
by Christophe Boussin
Hello all,

Thank you for these explanations Francois !!
This nova is definitely very surprising !!
We were able to record five new spectra at high resolution around the Halpha line during this month of November which effectively show the appearance of the forbidden lines of nitrogen [NII] at 6548 and 6583 A.

These solution spectra were obtained on November 3 at 23 h 44 TU (resolution of 18848, JJ = 2459522.4888, 9 x 600s), on November 5 at 23 h 30 TU (resolution of 18015, JJ = 2459524.479, 12 x 600s), on November 8 at 22 h 10 TU (resolution of 18471, JJ = 2459527.4238, 9 x 600s), on November 22 at 20 h 39 TU (resolution of 18488, JJ = 2459541.3604, 5 x 600s) and on November 23 at 19 h 41 TU (resolution of 19284, JJ = 2459542.3198, 12 x 600s) with a LHIRES III (grating of 2400 lines / mm).

Here are all the spectra we got between November 3th and November 23th :
Halpha line profile of the Nova CAS 2021 on November 3th, 5th, 8th, 22th and 23th 2021
Halpha line profile of the Nova CAS 2021 on November 3th, 5th, 8th, 22th and 23th 2021
The appearance of the forbidden lines of nitrogen [NII] at 6548 and 6583 A seems to be between November 4 and 6...Note the blue shift in wavelength of these lines !
The Halpha line profile itself has changed dramatically compared to October (see previous post) !
Halpha line profile of the Nova CAS 2021 (zero velocity is on Halpha at rest) on November 3th, 5th, 8th, 22th and 23th 2021
Halpha line profile of the Nova CAS 2021 (zero velocity is on Halpha at rest) on November 3th, 5th, 8th, 22th and 23th 2021
novacas2021_20211103_20211123_Halpha_velocity_Marion Thomas et Christophe Boussin.png (60.56 KiB) Viewed 6249 times
According to the AAVSO website, the magnitude of Nova Cas 2021 is increasing with oscillations : has the decline begun ?

(Johnson V : green squares)
Light curve of the Nova CAS 2021 (AAVSO)
Light curve of the Nova CAS 2021 (AAVSO)
We wish you all a very clear sky to follow this new evolution of the Nova Cas 2021 !!

Marion THOMAS and Christophe BOUSSIN

Re: Alert! Nova Cas 2021 mag 9

Posted: Fri Nov 26, 2021 6:38 pm
by Francois Teyssier
Correction to line identification of [NII] 6548, 6583:
A clue: Compare H alpha, H beta, He I profiles using PlotSpectra
Not a lot of comments ...

I recall the method: always compare the lines *between* them.

Well,
novacas2021_NII (002).png
novacas2021_NII (002).png (20.41 KiB) Viewed 6230 times
[NII] or the shape of the ejecta revealed by the remove of opacity?

has the decline begun ?
Yes, it is now probably (almost) frozen.
But for such an object any prevision is highly speculative.


François

Re: Alert! Nova Cas 2021 mag 9

Posted: Fri Nov 26, 2021 7:55 pm
by Christophe Boussin
Thank you for this comparison Francois !
Yes, indeed, the profiles of the Halpha and Hbeta lines are very similar...and the evolution of the shape of the Halpha line can give the same impression as the appearance of the [NII] lines at 6548 and 6583 A...To be continued !

Christophe

Re: Alert! Nova Cas 2021 mag 9

Posted: Sat Nov 27, 2021 10:10 am
by Francois Teyssier
The best way for a comparison of the profiles:
Normalisation of both the continuum and maximum intensity of the lines (here, resp: 1 & 10)
RSOph_Hbeta4861_Halpha6563_2021-11-09_741.png
RSOph_Hbeta4861_Halpha6563_2021-11-09_741.png (85.04 KiB) Viewed 6161 times

For Balmer series, do not hesitate to check also the lower members as they show more details (due to radiative processes)
Note the absorption in H gamma profile. Large parts of the nebula are still optically thick.
RSOph_Hgamma4340_Hbeta4861_Halpha6563_2021-11-09_741.png
RSOph_Hgamma4340_Hbeta4861_Halpha6563_2021-11-09_741.png (115.15 KiB) Viewed 6161 times
One can see easily from this sequence that H alpha is *not* the best line for the study of the phenomenon.


François